Sunbeam TR3000B and Goldair GETH230 heated throws

First Look: Goldair and Sunbeam heated throws

Heated throws let you stay toasty and warm anywhere in the home – as long as you’re within 2 metres of a power point. We bought 2 throws (a Sunbeam and Goldair) and got 3 Consumer staff to trial each one over a few cold, wintery days to find out if they were cosy delights or wet blankets.

×

Choose what’s right for you with confidence

Join today and get instant access to all test results and research.

How are they different from electric blankets?

A heated throw is a fleece blanket with a built-in heating system of wires, similar to an electric blanket. However, the wires inside heated throws are more flexible, which means you can snuggle up in one or lay it over yourself when you’re on the couch.

Both Sunbeam and Goldair have heated throws available in various fabrics, such as microfleece (which we trialled), sherpa fleece, faux fur and “luxurious velvet”.

Confusing instructions

The instructions we got with these heated throws left us scratching our heads – they were littered with references to electric blankets.

The Goldair instructions stated the throw should only be used on a bed before bedtime, but the packaging shows someone with it wrapped around them. We contacted Goldair and it said it can be used as a “cuddle” blanket or laid over the lap, and that someone was “overzealous” in copying the common instructions from electric blankets.

The Sunbeam had similar issues. Instructions on the controller said the lower 5 settings were for “all night use”, but the throw has an automatic 3-hour shut off. The controller is very similar to the one used on some electric blankets, so it seems Goldair wasn’t the only one to borrow from their electric blankets.

Washing

Both throws trialled have removable controllers, which means you can simply unplug the controller and put it in the washing machine. Detaching and reattaching controllers was usually easy, but some triallists had problems releasing the safety catch on the Goldair. Being machine washable means the odd spilt tea isn’t a danger, just put it in the wash.

The Sunbeam’s washing instructions are simple, put it on a gentle machine wash. The Goldair required 15 minutes of pre-soaking and then a gentle wash for 2 minutes. When was the last time you saw a washing machine with any wash cycle that short? Instead, we put it on a rinse and slow spin.

Line-drying was straightforward (don’t use pegs as they can crease the wires) though, in Wellington weather, they took 2 days to dry. You can accelerate the process by partially drying these throws in a clothes dryer, but you need to remove them while still damp (to prevent damage) and finish with line drying.

User trial: Sunbeam vs Goldair

Goldair GETH230

This microfleece throw was soft and cosy, with edges finished with piping. Our triallists described it as “very soft and cosy” and “a good size to wrap around yourself”. All triallists found it warmed them up well, but it was noticeably cool around the edges. This is because of its unheated border (90 to 100mm wide on the bottom and sides, and 140mm wide on the top).

It has 9 temperature settings and one 12-hour timer. Annoyingly, the timer display doesn’t count down to show how long is left until it turns off, leaving the user guessing – it caught out at least one triallist.

It has a generous 2.7m long cable (including from controller to the throw). Overall, this throw was comfortable, warm, and retained heat well.

Price: $150 (Briscoes exclusive)

Dimensions (WxL): 120cm x 160cm

Fabric: Microfleece

Heat settings: 9

Sunbeam TR3000B

Our triallists described this simple-looking throw as “very soft” with a weight comparable to a normal blanket. It provided plenty of warmth and comfort, even though it was noticeably thinner than the Goldair.

Triallists didn’t notice any hot or cold spots in the middle of the throw, though the unheated borders were cooler (180 to 220mm on the sides and 160 to 220mm top and bottom). The controls were easy to use, but not completely intuitive.

For example, its 2 power buttons left one triallist confused as to which actually controlled the throw (it’s both). It automatically turns off after 3 hours.

It has a 2.12m cord (including from the controller to the throw) and is edged with a simple blanket stitch, which meant it did start fraying around the stitches. Overall it was comfy and warm, but the quality of its construction and instructions could have been better.

Price: $170

Dimensions (WxL): 120cm x 160cm

Fabric: Microfleece

Heat settings: 6

Price

Most of the participants in our trial found the throws warm and comfortable and would buy one, if only they were a little cheaper. None would fork out more than $100 for a heated throw.

Time, temperature and energy

We didn’t put these throws through a lab test like we do electric blankets, but we did make a few observations using our office test equipment. The Sunbeam reached a maximum (pre-heat setting) of 29°C and the Goldair 26°C. Temperatures on middle settings averaged 24°C to 28°C. These are double-layered microfleece throws, so they retain heat once turned off.

Neither throw was particularly power-hungry. We checked energy consumption over 2 hours of use on a medium setting and both cost less than 5¢ per hour. Both throws were quick to warm up, taking between 3 and 4 minutes to reach pre-heat temperatures (though they claim to take longer).

Safety tips

  • The power cord can become a tripping hazard, especially for those with mobility issues, so make sure to keep it out of the way.
  • Creases or kinks in the wires can become a fire hazard. If one develops, replace the throw immediately.
  • Run your hand over the throw after it’s warmed up. If there are any areas that are noticeably hotter, replace the throw.
  • Pregnant women, babies or young children should not use electric blankets due to their higher levels of heat sensitivity.
  • When storing, roll the blanket (don’t fold) and make sure heavy objects aren’t stored on top.

Verdict

Both throws did what they claimed, keeping our triallists warm and comfortable. But if it came to a “throw down”, the triallists found the Goldair more comfortable. The Sunbeam still rated well with our triallists. All said they would buy one if they were cheaper.

Have your say

Interested in a full lab test of heated throws? Let us know by contacting erin@consumer.org.nz.

First Looks are trials of new and interesting products from the perspective of our product experts. Our lab-based tests offer truly objective product comparisons.


By Erin Bennett
Technical Writer


30aug promoimage default

First Looks

Cars, phones, infomercial products and anything else that takes our fancy — First Looks are trials of new or interesting products from the perspective of our product experts. Check out our latest.

Take a look