KiwiSaver satisfaction survey 2020

Our survey reveals the best and worst KiwiSaver providers when it comes to customer satisfaction.

KiwiSaver satisfaction survey

It’s been a tough few months for many KiwiSavers. Sharemarket falls have hit retirement nest eggs with $4.5 billion wiped off the value of funds in the year to March. Meanwhile, what we pay in fees has continued to rise, topping $479 million in 2019.

If you’ve got your KiwiSaver funds invested with AMP, ANZ or ASB, you’ve got other grounds to feel miffed. The three companies, among the biggest KiwiSaver schemes, scored below average in our latest customer satisfaction survey.

If you want better service, you’re more likely to get it from the smaller players.

Note: Our annual KiwiSaver survey was conducted before the current sharemarket drop following the Covid-19 crisis.

Satisfaction scores

Want to read the full article?

  • Heaps of buying advice so you can choose with confidence
  • Independent reviews of thousands of products and services
  • Personal advice an email or phone call away on our advice line (members only).

Information gaps

KiwiSaver has been running for more than a decade but our annual surveys show consumers still face big information gaps.

With 27 providers and more than 250 funds, KiwiSaver can be a tricky market to navigate. Not surprisingly, many consumers find it hard to compare schemes. Just 24% thought comparing providers was very easy.

In addition, 47% felt they didn’t have access to sufficient independent information and advice to help make decisions about their investment, or didn’t know what was available. That’s been a consistent finding of our survey for the past five years.

Many are also unsure about how their fund is managed.

Most KiwiSavers (76%) didn’t know what they paid in annual fees. Two-thirds were also unsure how their fund performed relative to the rest of the market.

Just 18% felt sure their KiwiSaver funds would be enough to support them in their retirement.


Ethics debate

KiwiSavers aren’t just worried about returns and fees. Many also want to know more about where their KiwiSaver funds are invested.

About half (49%) said they wanted a fund that provided a good return but also invested ethically. Another 14% put ethical investment ahead of returns.

Despite the appetite for responsible investment, many felt it was difficult to find out where their money was going.

As we’ve found in previous years, the majority said they’d be concerned if their money was supporting sin stocks, such as gambling, pornography or tobacco. But most didn’t know whether their fund manager excluded investment in these areas.

Six out of 10 KiwiSavers said they’d be very concerned if their money was invested in weapons but didn’t know whether their cash went into this industry. Investments in nuclear power and palm oil were also a major concern for half of investors.

Overall, just 24% felt sure their cash was invested responsibly.

Where do you stand?


Who’s keeping watch?

The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) is promising to keep closer tabs on the industry and what it’s delivering for consumers.

That pledge comes as companies’ income from fees continues to rise.

In 2019, KiwiSaver providers earned $479.8 million in fees, up 15% on 2018. Research commissioned by the FMA suggests what we’re paying is high compared with similar funds in the UK.

Last year, FMA director Liam Mason said it would be asking providers “to demonstrate how they are providing value for money for members”.

Mr Mason said this would include getting providers to explain “how higher fees are justified for services such as active fund management or responsible investment strategies”.

As our survey shows, higher fees haven’t translated into quality customer service.

Where's your money going?

Finding out which horses your KiwiSaver cash is backing isn’t as straightforward as it could be.

KiwiSaver providers must regularly disclose the top 10 investments of each of their funds. They also have to file financial statements and lists of fund holdings showing where money is invested. These returns are held on the Companies Office Disclose Register. But in many cases, the information doesn’t tell you everything you need to know. Most schemes invest in global tracking funds, which means you need to dig deeper to find where these funds invest.

It’s a safe bet the majority will have holdings in stock exchange leaders and big name companies – think Apple, Microsoft, Facebook, BP, ExxonMobil, Shell, Nestle, Coca-Cola, PepsiCo and McDonald’s among others.

The online Disclose Register is free to access, although you need to know where to look for relevant information. To find your KiwiSaver fund’s holdings, search under “Offers” and enter the name of your provider. A list of “Full portfolio holdings” can be found under the “Investment Options” tab.

You’re entitled to ask your provider where it’s investing your money. Quiz your fund manager about its approach to responsible investment. Look for details on industries the fund screens, rather than general commitments to do the right thing. You can also ask what the fund is doing to support sustainability investing.

Nine KiwiSaver funds are promoted as dedicated responsible investment options:

  • AMP’s Responsible Investment Balanced Fund
  • ANZ’s OneAnswer Sustainable International Share Fund
  • Booster’s Socially Responsible Investment Balanced Fund, and Socially Responsible Investment Growth Fund
  • CareSaver's Balanced, Conservative and Growth funds
  • QuayStreet’s Balanced SRI Fund
  • SuperLife’s Ethica Fund.

These funds exclude a broader range of investments than the companies’ other KiwiSaver offerings. Common exclusions include alcohol, arms, gambling and pornography. Investment in fossil fuel extraction is also excluded by Booster, QuayStreet and SuperLife.

Compare KiwiSaver returns & fees

Compare KiwiSaver returns & fees

New Zealand cash and coins beside a black wallet.

Compare KiwiSaver returns & fees

Chasing high returns? Compare fees plus 5-year and 12-month returns across a range of fund types.

Compare now

Banks and banking

Banks and banking

16apr banks and banking clp promo

Banks and banking

From credit cards to mortgages, we’ll help you make the right choices when managing your finances.

Learn more

Stay in the know

Keep up-to-date with Consumer's latest news, investigations and product and service reviews, plus join the Consumer panel with invitations to take part in surveys.

Member comments

Get access to comment

Yolanda S.
16 May 2020
What about Caresaver?

I switched to Caresaver as I want to be sure my money is invested in an ethical way. I am really surprised not to see Caresaver mentioned (unless I missed it) and their investments do well too. They are head and shoulders above all the others in their ethics and they walk the talk with 20% of their fees donated to charity.

Kevin H.
16 May 2020
Also strong support for CareSaver

I would be interested to know why they are not included. I did a lot of research and some switching around before landing on CareSaver. Now for the first time I’m entirely comfortable both with its financial performance and its ethical performance

jon s.
20 May 2020
Caresaver

Caresaver is listed here under Pathfinder Asset Management

Consumer staff
28 May 2020
Re: CareSaver

Hi Yolanda, Kevin

We didn't get enough responses from CareSaver members to include the company in our survey. We need a minimum of 30 responses to be able to show satisfaction ratings for a provider.

Thanks,
Fonda - Consumer NZ staff