How good at background heating are cheap-to-run flat-panel heaters?
Unlock all of Consumer from just $7 for 7 days
Low-wattage wall-mounted flat-panel heaters are heavily promoted as being cheap to run and there are several makes on the market.
Most flat-panel heaters deliver around 400W of heat, although other wattages are available. They're usually mounted on 4 spacers to keep them away from the wall. Some have timers as well. They’re cheap to run. At current electricity prices, a 400W flat-panel heater costs 9.2 cents an hour to run ($2.21 per day if left on for 24 hours).
Low running costs are one thing … but do they do a good job of keeping a typical bedroom warm? To find out we tested a 400W flat-panel heater against a dehumidifier and a 2300W thermostatically-controlled oil-column heater.
We tested an Econoheat 0603 400W flat panel heater, a DeLonghi CF08M dehumidifier and an Evantair TWNDB1EIII-11T 2300W oil column heater.
We tested them in a special "room inside a room". The inner test room was a typical size for a bedroom (3 metres by 4 metres and 2.4 metres high). It had insulated ceilings and walls.
Before the start of each test run, both the inner and outer rooms were stabilised at 8°C. Throughout the test runs – while the inner room warmed up – the outer room was maintained at 8°C. We monitored the temperature of the inner test room with 72 evenly placed sensors.
Dehumidifiers and heating
It may seem strange to use a dehumidifier to heat a room. But dehumidifiers deliver more heat to the room than they use in electricity – so they warm and dry the air. For a fuller explanation see our dehumidifiers test.
The fastest at heating the room was the oil-column heater – it took only 8.2 minutes to raise the room temperature by 2°C. Almost as fast was the dehumidifier at 8.8 minutes. But the flat-panel heater took 21 minutes to heat the room even by this modest amount.
The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends that bedroom temperatures not drop below 16°C. So we set the thermostat of the oil-column heater to 16°C and waited to see how long it took to get there. It did it within an hour – and then the thermostat cycled on and off to maintain this temperature for the remaining hour of our test run. It used 45 cents worth of electricity over the 2-hour period.
Over a 24-hour period the oil-column heater would cost $5.36 in power but provide a much better level of heating than a flat-panel heater. If used overnight for 12 hours, it would cost about the same as a flat-panel heater running for 24 hours.
How did the dehumidifier and the flat-panel heater compare?
The dehumidifier initially raised the temperature quite quickly but tailed off, giving a final temperature of 11.6°C at the end of the 2 hours. The dehumidifier used 11 cents worth of electricity over the 2 hours (which shows that it’s a cost-effective way of providing a relatively small amount of heating).
The flat-panel heater slowly raised the temperature to 12.2°C after 2 hours and used 19 cents worth of electricity.
Our graph shows the relative performance of each of the heating options.
Tip: You can check the temperature of your room with an inexpensive digital room thermometer. They’re available for less than $20.
To help us get a fair deal for all New Zealanders, you can make a donation or bequest. We’ll use your contribution to investigate consumer issues and work for positive change.
Consumer Powerswitch lets you check if you could save money on electricity and gas. Just enter your details into the calculator to find the cheapest energy deals.
Unlock all of Consumer from just $7 for 7 days or become a member from just $12 p/m