Updated 3 Oct 2017


Index Smart Scale 010-01591-10

Snapshot: The Garmin Index Smart Scale 010-01591-10 has a capacity up to 181kg and can store 15 user profiles. But how accurate is it?

Index Smart Scale 010-01591-10
Consumer score
Avg price


Price comparison

Join us now to unlock this content

Unlock all of Consumer from just $12 a month

  • Heaps of buying advice so you can choose with confidence
  • Independent reviews of thousands of products and services
  • Personal advice an email or phone call away on our advice line (members only)
Log in

Test results

Overall score
Body fat accuracy
Body fat deviation
Weight accuracy
Weight sensitivity
Ease of use

Good points

  • Good body fat accuracy.
  • Good weight accuracy.
  • Very good weight sensitivity.
  • OK to use.
  • Display OK to read.
  • Identifies previous set users (although if more than one user has a similar weight measurements can get confused).
  • Has Wi-Fi connectivity.
  • Last measurements of the day are logged on the app for review.


  • No controls on scale (control is through an app on a smartphone or tablet).
  • Very difficult to set up.

How we test

We took readings from 15 men and women. We then compared the results with those obtained from a DEXA (Dual-Energy X-ray Absorptiometre) scan, a machine used in hospitals for determining body fat composition.

Overall score includes:

Body fat accuracy (25%) - How accurately the scale measured body fat.
Weight accuracy (20%) - How accurately the scale measured body weight.
Weight sensitivity (10%) - How sensitive the scale was in detecting incremental changes of 100g.
Body fat deviation (15%) - Based on the reading that was furthest away from the DEXA scan. Measures how much it varied from the scan.
Ease of use (30%) - How easy the display was to read; how easy the controls were to programme and push with your toe; feet positioning; and how stable the scale was to stand on.

Key data


Avg price


HxWxD (cm)
4 x 35 x 31
Capacity (kg)
User profiles
4 x AA


Identify previous set users
Can sync results with other products
Body Mass Index
Water %
Muscle %
Bone %

More Info