Find out which type of cooktop will best suit your needs, the features to look for, and compare test results for all 3 types.
Snapshot: The Whirlpool ACM795BA induction cooktop has five cooking zones, which includes a flexi-zone. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Whirlpool ACM828BA induction cooktop has 4 cooking zones but there’s no auto heat-up. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Whirlpool AKT809BA ceramic cooktop has 4 elements and touch controls. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Robinhood Alto HGAA604FKSS gas cooktop has 4 burners and flame-failure protection. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Bellini BDG604G-F gas cooktop has 4 burners and flame-failure protection. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Bellini BG905X gas cooktop has 5 burners and flame-failure protection. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Everdure CBGS62 gas cooktop has 4 burners and flame-failure protection. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Fisher & Paykel CE604CBX1 ceramic cooktop has 4 elements, and dial controls. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Fisher & Paykel CE604DTB1 ceramic cooktop has 4 elements, and touch controls. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Fisher & Paykel CE754DTB1 ceramic cooktop has 4 elements and touch controls. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Fisher & Paykel CG604DNGGB1 gas cooktop has 4 burners and flame-failure protection. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Fisher & Paykel CG604DX1 gas cooktop has 4 burners and flame-failure protection. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Blanco CG604WXFFC gas cooktop has 4 burners and flame-failure protection. How well does it cook?
Snapshot: The Fisher & Paykel CG905DNGGB1 gas cooktop has 5 burners and flame-failure protection. How well does it cook?
Unlock all of Consumer from just $7 for 7 days
Turn the heat off a radiant-ceramic element that's been on full for a few minutes and it takes some time for the element to cool. Turn off a gas flame and the heat's gone. Professional chefs overwhelmingly use gas for stovetop cooking because it gives them better and more responsive control over the heat. If you're at all adventurous with your cooking, gas is likely to suit you better.
Induction cooktops may offer the best of both worlds: the sleek good looks of ceramic cooktops with the speed and instant control of gas cooking. They heat up incredibly quickly, transferring energy to the cookware faster than any other method of cooking. Induction cooktops are also excellent from a safety perspective: since the element itself does not get hot, it’s safe to touch unless you’ve had a hot pan on it for a while.
With any cooktop, you need to consider installation issues – adequate ventilation and connection to power and fuel supplies. With induction cooktops you also need to invest in new cookware – the cookware used on induction cooktops must be made of ferrous (iron) materials. Pots and pans also need to be within, or close to, the diameter of the elements. Cookware that overhangs won’t heat properly around the edges, and pans that are too small won’t be recognised.
If you’re installing a new cooktop, we recommend getting a quote for installation before buying one – especially if you’re moving from a radiant-ceramic cooktop to an induction or gas cooktop.
First we make white sauce on the simmer-burner or element with the lowest setting. This tests the cooktop’s ability to perform at a low temperature for a long time.
Next we cook rice on the medium-sized burner or element. This tests the "turn down" capacity of the hob and whether the cooktop can maintain a suitable heat at the lowest temperature setting.
We then use a beef and vegetable stir-fry to see whether the cooktop can deliver continuous high heat.
We also assessed the ease of use and cleaning of each cooktop.
Total number surveyed: 1954
Cooktops in our survey are evenly split between gas, ceramic and induction models. Induction cooktops have slightly better-than-average reliability (93% didn’t need repair), while gas cooktops are less reliable (88% didn’t need repair).
Bosch and Ariston are the most reliable brands with 97% free from repair. Bosch owners are satisfied with their cooktop (82% very satisfied).
Many cooks prefer gas because it gives instant heat control and the flame shows how hot the burner will be. It's also great for wok cooking. But parts of the country don't have a piped-in natural gas supply.
Even where gas is an option, getting connected can be very expensive.
The alternative is liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), which can be supplied in twin 45kg bottles attached to the outside of the house and reticulated inside.
If you use gas only for your cooktop, the most cost effective option is to hook it up to a small 9kg cylinder, installed either outside the house, which is preferable, or in a cupboard next to the cooktop. When the gas runs out, you can get it refilled at a service station.
If the cylinder is installed inside it's very important that the cupboard is adequately vented to the outside and that there are no electrical sockets or switches inside the cupboard. The hose and fittings must be LPG-approved. Brush a solution of water and dishwashing liquid on the connections each time you reconnect the cylinder after refilling. If bubbles appear, LPG is leaking.
If you're likely to want to change fuels, say from natural gas to LPG, check whether the model you're interested in can be converted after purchase. A licensed gasfitter must perform the conversion for you.
Fisher & Paykel's Izona CookSurface claims to combine the performance of a gas cooktop with the easy-to-clean convenience of a ceramic top. So what do you get for almost $4000?
You certainly get good looks. The 3 "hidden" burners, the pan supports (not conventional trivets) and the control dials all sit flush with the sleek black top. When you push the control dial the burner and pan supports rise; and the burner ignites at the same time. Once cooking is finished and the surface cools, the burner and the supports automatically retract.
You also get extra features like a child lock ... and beeps and lights when you push buttons and turn dials.
The 3-in-a-row layout of the burners means no reaching over a hot pot to get to one at the back. But it also means only 3 burners compared with 4 or 5 on the other cooktops.
It's not as easy to clean as a regular ceramic cooktop. Cleaning can be fiddly with 5 separate pieces around each burner to remove, clean and replace. The pan supports must be kept clean, too, so that they can retract properly.
As well, the cooktop's flat surface allows spills to run on to the bench – and there are no seals around the controls to stop spills from running into the workings.
Consumer Powerswitch lets you check if you could save money on electricity and gas. Just enter your details into the calculator to find the cheapest energy deals.
Check out more of our tests, articles, news and surveys in our Appliances section.
Unlock all of Consumer from just $7 for 7 days or become a member from just $12 p/m