Do you really need to fork out for both?
It can be tough picking the perfect household surface cleaner – should you buy a kitchen cleaner, or will a multi-purpose product do the job?
We’re dedicated to getting NZ consumers a fairer deal. We provide as much information as we can for free but we rely primarily on membership and donations to fund our work. You can help by becoming a Consumer member or making a donation. We’ll use your contribution to investigate consumer issues and work for positive change.
We've tested 21 multi-purpose and kitchen cleaners.Find a surface cleaner
We tested both multi-purpose and kitchen cleaners. We found multi-purpose products, which can clean most household surfaces, were the best performers overall.
However, there were a lot of poor performers. Almost half of the cleaners in our test were no better than water, earning our Don’t Buy warning. Just four multi-purpose cleaners and one kitchen cleaner were good enough to recommend.
Follow the instructions on the label and spray a coin-sized amount on to the surface you want to clean (do this in an area where it won’t matter if it gets damaged). Wait a few hours to see if the product harms the surface.
Always check the pack to see which other surfaces should be avoided – we found a wide variety of “unsafe” surfaces listed.
Unless the product’s label specifically says you can, you shouldn’t use multi-purpose cleaners on these surfaces:
Always keep your cleaners away from children — ideally in a high or locked cupboard.
If anyone swallows cleaning product, immediately rinse out their mouth with water and phone your doctor or the National Poisons Centre (0800 POISON).
Some cleaners claim the waste, or “grey”, water is safe for other uses, such as watering the garden. If you are using grey water in your garden, we suggest not using it on food that will be eaten raw.
Some cleaners state they kill a certain percentage of bacteria, but there is little evidence antibacterial cleaners stop bacteria spreading in a home. There is even the risk they contribute to antibiotic resistance in the environment.
We’ve assessed how well these products clean. Our test is comparative, which means the products are compared to each other – not to a defined standard of “clean”.
We are developing an assessment of the impact of these cleaners on the environment, and the use of the products with septic tanks and greywater systems.
We’ll update this test with environmental results when we have them. For more information before then, see our article on whether cleaning products green claims stack up.