Join ConsumerLoginDonate
  • Consumer NZ
  • About us
  • Consumer rights and advice
  • Subscribe to our newsletters
  • Media releases
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Community guidelines
  • Contact us
  • Membership
  • Join
  • Membership support
  • Consumer magazine
  • Consumer Advice Line
  • Top tests and reviews
  • Other sites
  • Campaigns
  • Stop misleading supermarket pricing
  • Fix the broken electricity market
  • Sign the flight rights petition
  • Stamp out scams
  • Right to repair
  • End greenwashing now

Follow us

© Copyright Consumer NZ. All rights reserved.

Best and worst insurance providers in 2024

Updated 28 January 2025
Rebecca  2

By Rebecca Styles

Research Lead | Hautū Rangahau

We’ve seen a slight uptick in 2024 in overall customer satisfaction with insurance, except for health insurance, where satisfaction has dropped.

On this page

  • About our survey
  • House and contents insurance
  • Car insurance
  • Health insurance
  • Life insurance
  • Travel insurance
  • New law for fairer insurance contracts

Two insurers are doing a stellar job for house, contents and car insurance, while banks are doing well for travel insurance. Overall satisfaction with life insurers is still mediocre.

There have also been legislative reforms in the insurance contracts space, creating a couple of new fishhooks for consumers to be aware of.

Website promo image 1290 x 860  63  width

About our survey

Our survey took place online in October 2024 – 6,415 respondents made up of Consumer NZ members, supporters and a nationally representative sample of the public took part. Insurers named in our results are those mentioned in 30 responses or more.

Overall satisfaction shows the percentage of respondents who rated their insurer 8, 9 or 10 on a scale from 0 (very dissatisfied) to 10 (very satisfied).

We give our People’s Choice award to providers that rate above average for customer satisfaction and meet our other performance criteria. Learn more about People's Choice.

House and contents insurance

Want to read the full article?

  • Thousands of expert product/service reviews

  • Personal support through our Consumer Rights Advice Line

  • Premium articles and in-depth buying advice

  • Add a Consumer magazine for even more exclusive content

Join Consumer
LoginLearn more

Car insurance

Health insurance

Life insurance

Travel insurance

New law for fairer insurance contracts


Join donate promo

We can't do this without you.

As an independent non-profit, we depend on the generous support of our members and donors to keep us fighting for a better deal.

Join




Comments

Get access to comment
Join Consumer
Log in

Was this page helpful?

Related articles

Insurance premium width

8 ways to save on insurance

August 2025
Image of a map

The 5 most common travel insurance claims

14 August 2023
hearts on a keyboard

Scams and how to avoid them

Close-up of person typing on a laptop keyboard.

Laptop reviews

Updated July 2025