Consumer NZ has been tracking the sale prices of products and found some stores need to be reminded of the definition of a “special” price. The independent watchdog judged Briscoes’ promotions the easiest to trust as genuine sales, while Noel Leeming’s discounts were the hardest to gauge.
Consumer says the promotional patter of some stores could mislead shoppers about the quality of the “bargains” on offer – and risk breaching the Fair Trading Act (FTA).
To reach these findings, it tracked the prices of 13 products over 12 weeks at five retailers: Briscoes, Farmers, Harvey Norman, JB Hi-Fi and Noel Leeming.

Get 50% off our Sale Season Pass
We’ll help you dodge the duds and find the deals worth your hard-earned cash.
How easy is it to spot a genuine special? Stores ranked from top to flop
According to the FTA, an advertised “sale” must be a genuine opportunity to buy a product at a discounted price for a short period of time. Consumer says the promotional language it observed makes it increasingly hard to tell whether you're getting a genuinely good deal.
With that in mind, Consumer has ranked stores on how easy it is to spot a genuine sale in their promotional “deals”, from easiest to hardest, based on its price tracking.
Briscoes
Briscoes was top of the shops when it came to clearly communicating a genuine opportunity to save. The prices repeatedly returned to full price between promotions, and Briscoes used less promotional language and labelling than the other stores.
“Everyone knows Briscoes has a lot of sales. What sets Briscoes apart from the other stores is that prices don’t fluctuate as much. Our analysis showed products are either on sale, generally at up to 50% off their highest price, or they’re full price,” says Rebecca Styles, research lead at Consumer.
“Given the regularity of sales at Briscoes, you should feel sorry for yourself if you pay full price for a product there.”
However, just because a product is on special at Briscoes, it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the best available price.
“Across the three months we were tracking the sales, the best price Briscoes offered for a specific Ninja air fryer was $125. The same product at Noel Leeming dropped to $97.”
Farmers
Farmers edged into second place because some of its promotional language risked causing consumer confusion.
“At Farmers, we observed a regular pattern of a product being on sale for a few weeks before returning to full price. But its use of a ‘great price’ label let the store down. The term ‘great price’ didn’t reliably indicate a low price,” says Styles.
For example, a top-loader washing machine at Farmers was labelled as a “great price” every week for 12 weeks. That “great price” varied from $1,248 to $1,669.
A Samsung heat-pump dryer was labelled as a “great price” at $1,399 and was still classed as a “great price” when it was selling for $1,989 a few weeks later.
JB Hi-Fi
Consumer ranked JB Hi-Fi third because its use of promotional language on some products didn’t equate to a clearly good deal.
“A Breville Barista Express was ‘on sale’ for $600, and a week later it was a ‘red hot deal’ at $698. It was also a ‘red hot deal’ at $848. Some of these descriptions ceased to be meaningful,” says Styles.
The highest price of the coffee machine at JB Hi-Fi was $999. So while the “specials” were all an opportunity to save, the widespread use of hyperbole made it hard to distinguish the level of discount.
Harvey Norman
Harvey Norman slid into fourth place. After Consumer carried out a similar investigation last year, it called the retailer out for its bamboozling use of promotional language across most tracked products, most weeks.
“We are pleased to see that Harvey Norman has stopped using as many promotional labels. However, we still found examples of labels being used to promote a price that wasn’t a particularly good deal,” says Styles.
The not-so-special pricing at Harvey Norman included a handheld garment steamer that was $34 cheaper when it wasn’t labelled a “hot deal” and an air fryer that was $10 cheaper when it wasn’t a “birthday deal” or “hot deal”.
Noel Leeming
Bottom of the pack was Noel Leeming. This store was particularly heavy-handed with its promotional labels, including “price smash”, “epic deals”, “massive sellout” and “mega deals”.
“It’s impossible to know which promotional label represents the biggest opportunity to save,” says Styles.
A Ninja air fryer had a promotional label attached for all 11 of the price-tracking weeks it was available. It was $129 in a “massive sellout”, but people who paid the “price smash” price got a better deal at $97.
However, “price smash” didn’t always mean the best bargain. A Philips garment steamer was $22 more expensive with a “price smash” label than it was the week before, with no promotional label.
“A stark example of problematic promotional pricing was a Breville Barista available at a ‘mega deal’ of $869. That ‘mega deal’ was the highest price we tracked for that product at Noel Leeming. The mega deal was actually a meagre deal,” says Styles.
How to shop the sales with confidence
Consumer urges shoppers to track product prices rather than rely on promotional price claims and says there are genuine savings to be had.
“Our team is continually tracking prices this sale season, helping our members to spot bona fide bargains that are based on both price and product performance,” says Styles.
Consumer is offering a sale season savings pass, with 50% off a 3-month membership. Members will have access to deals of the week, featuring the Consumer team’s pick of the best of the sales, as well as expert buying advice.



