Join ConsumerLoginDonate
  • Consumer NZ
  • About us
  • Consumer rights and advice
  • Subscribe to our newsletters
  • Media releases
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Community guidelines
  • Contact us
  • Membership
  • Join
  • Membership support
  • Consumer magazine
  • Consumer Advice Line
  • Top tests and reviews
  • Other sites
  • Campaigns
  • Stop misleading supermarket pricing
  • Fix the broken electricity market
  • Sign the flight rights petition
  • Stamp out scams
  • Right to repair
  • End greenwashing now

Follow us

© Copyright Consumer NZ. All rights reserved.

Best whitening toothpastes in NZ: what actually works

18 March 2026
Vanessa profile

By Vanessa Pratley

Investigative Journalist | Kaipūrongo Whakatewhatewha

With dozens of toothpastes on supermarket and pharmacy shelves, it can be tricky to know what one to pick, especially if your goal is whiter teeth.

Whitening toothpastes available in the NZ market.

In the world of ‘whitening’ toothpastes, ingredients are everything. So, we’ve done the hard work and reviewed 15 whitening toothpastes’ ingredients and claims.

On this page

  • How do whitening toothpastes work?
  • Types of teeth staining
  • Whitening toothpastes ranked

How do whitening toothpastes work?

Whitening toothpastes contain abrasives to help remove stains. They may also include ingredients that prevent stains from forming. However, they’re generally only able to remove surface stains rather than whitening your teeth. 

Types of teeth staining

Whether your teeth can be whitened depends on a few things, including what kind of stains you’ve got.

There are two types of stain: extrinsic (surface) and intrinsic (deep).

Extrinsic stains occur when the stain attaches itself to the pellicle (a thin layer of protein that forms on your teeth every day from saliva) or takes hold in the pores of tooth enamel.

Cigarettes, tea, coffee or red wine will cause extrinsic stains. So will highly coloured foods like berries, such as cherries.

Intrinsic stains sit below the tooth’s surface and are very difficult to remove using home treatments. There are a few common causes of intrinsic staining.

  • Ageing: Wear and tear thins the outer enamel; the dentine layer below then begins to show through, making the teeth appear yellow.

  • Antibiotics: Tetracylcine antibiotic use during certain stages of tooth development can cause discolouration.

  • Fluorosis: If children swallow too much fluoride toothpaste when their teeth are developing, they risk developing fluorosis or surface mottling on the teeth.

  • Root canal work: A tooth can sometimes darken following this procedure.

Genetics and injuries to the teeth and gums can also contribute to tooth discolouration.

Whitening toothpastes ranked

Image of a dentist holding dental tools

Dentist fees: What you can expect to pay

For plenty of us, the thought of the dentist’s bill is worse than the drill. Here's what you can expect to pay for a trip to the dentist.

Read more

Comments

Get access to comment
Join Consumer
Log in

Was this page helpful?

Related articles

Image of Hismile whitening strips

Hismile: Can it really brighten your teeth?

Dentist fees promo

Dentist treatment costs: What you can expect to pay in New Zealand

Red and green superfood powders.

Superfood powders: Do the health claims stack up?

Vitamin gummies.

7 reasons your kids don’t need vitamin gummies