Car clamping

The legal basis for clamping is dubious and we’ve calling for it to be banned.

Car with clamped wheel

My car recently got clamped! I’d parked in an empty carpark and was gone for about 10 minutes but had to pay the guy with the wheel clamp $200 to release my vehicle. How can they get away with this?

Wheel clampers are no strangers to complaints. Their stand-over tactics and steep fees continue to hit the headlines.

There are good reasons to question the practice. The legal basis for clamping is dubious and we’ve been calling for it to be banned.

How do they justify it?

Wheel clampers argue carpark signage makes clear the terms and conditions of parking. They claim consumers accept these terms when they park, so if they break the rules and get clamped it’s a fair cop. However, that argument quickly falls flat when signs are unclear, a common complaint, or lacking altogether.

If the conditions of parking are wholly unreasonable, it’s also unlikely they’d stand up in court. You’d be hard-pressed to find any reasonable consumer who thought it was fair to let clampers seize a vehicle parked in a shopping centre carpark for a few minutes and charge $200 (or more) to release it.

Another defence clampers use is a centuries-old remedy called “distress damage feasant”, originally intended to aid folk whose land was damaged by wandering livestock. If a cow strayed on to your pasture in rural England, you could hold on to it and demand payment from its owner for crop damage.

But applying this right to cars parked on private land is a different matter. It’s clear to us the hefty fees clampers charge show they’re more concerned with making a quick buck than recouping any alleged damage caused by a parked vehicle.

We're calling for a ban

Other countries have already outlawed clamping. The practice was banned in England and Wales in 2012. Scotland banned it in 1992.

Attempts to clean up the industry here through voluntary codes of practice haven’t worked. Fortunately, change is on the horizon. Both transport minister Phil Twyford and consumer affairs minister Kris Faafoi have said they want to clamp down on the clampers.

A ban is the best option. Trying to regulate this cowboy industry through licensing or other means would be costly and unlikely to work.

There are better ways for carpark operators to control what happens on their property than clamping. They can ticket cars that breach the carpark’s terms and conditions – similar to what happens when you park on a public street and stay longer than you should.

This would be a much fairer way to deal with the matter. Consumers would also be able to challenge breach notices issued unfairly – instead of having to fork out for the clamper’s bill without any right to dispute the matter before paying.

Support our call for a ban

If you want to support our call to get clamping banned, email transport minister Phil Twyford and consumer affairs minister Kris Faafoi asking them to outlaw the practice:

Got a problem?

Got a problem?

Got a problem?

The Consumer Advice Line is available to all our members for support on any consumer-related issue. Our expert advisers can explain your rights and help you resolve problems with a retailer.

Contact us now

Member comments

Get access to comment

Linda C.
26 May 2018
Car Clamping-Total ban unjustified?

I read the stories relating to clamping cars in parking lots, & agree there are better ways, in the main, to deal with these. However, I have seen advocates for wheel clamping to help solve Freedom Camping in banned areas. The argument is that most are just passing through & can drive off without paying their fine, whereas if the vehicle is immobilised they would have to pay or forfeit the vehicle. This reality would be shared via social media & cut down instances of people degrading the environment as now happens in formerly pristine areas. Obviously you couldn't tow a vehicle with the campers inside, but the downside would be trying to apply a clamp with hostile campers around. I'm sure technology will solve the problem of unpaid fines and/or temporarily immobilising vehicles, but clamping by AUTHORISED people seems to me a legitimate option where others are impractical.