Skip to content
Media releases
13 December 2022

House and contents insurance costs are a growing concern

Our insurance customer satisfaction survey shows an increase in insurance costs and a lacklustre performance from the industry.

The rising cost of house insurance is concerning many New Zealanders. Our insurance provider satisfaction survey found half of respondents were worried about the cost of insuring their homes.

Alarmingly, 7% of people without house insurance either cancelled or didn’t renew their policy because of cost. For those without contents insurance, 17% didn’t renew their policy for that same reason.

“Insurance provides a crucial safety net,” said Rebecca Styles, our investigative team leader. “With the cost of living squeezing many households, some New Zealanders have effectively been priced out of insurance protection.”

According to Consumer Price Index (CPI) data, the cost of house and contents insurance has increased by 150% over the past 10 years.

Our premium price survey found standard-sized houses in Hamilton have been hardest hit by insurance premium hikes.

“The cost of insuring a standard house in Hamilton has increased by a whopping 17% compared to this time last year,” said Styles.

“Over the past year, the cost has increased by 15% in Auckland, and by 14% in Dunedin.”

“Last year’s survey found Wellington was the most expensive region to insure a standard and large home. However, this year, price hikes for insuring Wellington’s homes are relatively modest compared to other regions – up 5% for a standard house and 9% for a large house.”

What’s driving the price increases

From 1 October this year, the Earthquake Commission (EQC) levy, which is paid with insurance premiums, rose from $345 to a maximum of $552.

This increased levy pays for a higher building cap. Essentially this means EQC will cover the first $300,000 worth of damage caused by earthquakes, tsunamis, volcanic eruptions, hydrothermal activity and natural landslips. Previously EQC would only cover the first $150,000.

The increased building cap means the Government is taking on more risk than private insurers.

Last year, Dr David Clark, the Minister for the Earthquake Commission, said the increased cap should lead to reduced premiums for many New Zealanders. However, Our research has shown median price increases across the regions.

“We found the median costs increased between 5 and 17% since this time last year,” said Styles.

Customer satisfaction low

Aside from eye-watering price hikes impacting policy holders, our insurance customer satisfaction survey found lacklustre performance when it comes to insurers keeping their customers satisfied. There are a few exceptions.

“The Medical Assurance Society (MAS) and FMG (previously Farmers’ Mutual Group) rated highly for customers with house and contents insurance.

“MAS and FMG got top scores for price, customer support and value for money.”

MAS and FMG are winners of our People’s Choice awards for house, contents and car insurance.

Three banks stood out for below-average performance in the house and contents insurance area: ASB, BNZ and Westpac.

"A review of the insurance industry to ensure it is competitive and working for households is well overdue," said Styles.

Photo of woman checking insurance bills

Best and worst insurance providers

While insurance premiums are rising, customer satisfaction is falling. However, there are a few insurers keeping people happy.

Read more