Countdown, New World and Pak’nSave are in the midst of ditching single-use plastic bags. The move can be chalked up as a win for consumer pressure. But what are the stores doing about the huge amount of other plastic packaging lining their shelves?
Join today and get instant access to all test results and research.
As well as scrapping plastic bags at the check-out, supermarkets promised to take the “reduce, reuse, recycle” message to heart throughout their stores. But our recent survey found basic steps to cut plastic waste weren’t always being taken.
We went shopping at three Wellington supermarkets to assess the plastic containers being used in their produce and bakery departments.
To help recyclers sort materials, most plastic carries a code (numbered one to seven). Without a code, it’s likely to end up at the landfill.
In Countdown’s bakery and produce sections, we found seven types of container (14%) with no recycling number. This included one tub of its store-brand Select cheesecake.
At New World, 8% of containers – including a plastic tray for its store-brand lamington squares – also lacked a recycling code. At Pak’nSave, the figure was 9%.
Countdown not only had the highest proportion of plastics without a recycling code, it also had the lowest use of recycled plastic packaging – known as “RPET”. Just 16% of containers we found at the Wellington store were labelled as previously recycled plastic.
Of the Countdown store-brand items in our stocktake, only three out of 16 (Countdown cherry tomatoes, Countdown Hersheys choc chip cookies and Countdown iced cupcakes) came in RPET-labelled packs.
At New World, 31% of plastic packs were labelled as RPET. Just over a quarter of containers at Pak’nSave were made using previously recycled plastic and 43% of the supermarket’s store brands came in packs bearing the RPET mark.
However, none of the 11 Pams products – a New World and Pak’nSave store brand – came in RPET-labelled containers.
If supermarkets are serious about addressing their plastic problem, ditching virgin plastic in their store-brand products is an easy place to start. Switching to plastic with recycled content could drastically cut the amount of new plastic being produced for their products.
The stores also have the market power to influence local producers. In our survey, we spotted plenty of examples of excessive plastic packaging: from a Rockit tube containing five apples to a Soup Pack tray holding carrots, onions, parsnip, celery and a swede.
Some fruit and vege – such as cherry tomatoes at New World and Countdown – were only sold in plastic containers. There was no way for a shopper to avoid this plastic.
Both Countdown and Foodstuffs – owner of the New World and Pak'nSave brands – have pledged to use 100% reusable, recyclable or compostable packaging in their own brands by 2025. However, 94% of the store-brand containers in our survey were already recyclable. The rest were made from uncoded plastic.
Countdown said its bakeries would switch to RPET – made from locally recycled plastic – for all packaging by the end of October. In the same month, it will stop stocking plastic straws. Countdown general manager corporate affairs Kiri Hannifin said it was reviewing plastic packaging on its store brands, including food and non-food products.
“Our goal for our own brands is that, wherever possible, we’re using recycled plastic and that it’s then able to be recycled at the end of its life – or, even better, that we’re not reliant on plastic packaging in the first place,” Ms Hannifin said.
Foodstuffs wouldn’t commit to a full switch to RPET but said it aimed to reduce plastic packaging “wherever feasible”. Foodstuffs head of external relations Antoinette Laird said both New World and Pak'nSave were reviewing store brand packaging to ensure it's reusable or recyclable.
Ms Laird said some New World supermarkets in the South Island are trialling a programme (dubbed “Food in the Nude”) to cut plastic use in the produce department. In October, both New World and Pak’nSave will cease selling plastic-stemmed cotton buds.
Two plastic manufacturers, which sell containers to food producers and supermarkets, said they had started replacing virgin plastic with RPET. As these new versions are rolled out, six items in the Pams range will be repackaged in previously recycled plastic. The amount of RPET in New World and Pak’nSave bakery and produce departments will also increase but the timeframe for this is uncertain.
Most hard plastic packaging in supermarkets’ bakery and produce sections is polyethylene terephthalate (PET). It carries the recycling code “1”.
Used PET plastic from soft-drink bottles, condiment jars and food trays can be broken down into flakes, which are then used to make recycled PET (RPET) packaging. This recycling process can happen over and over.
RPET packaging typically contains between 10% and 100% recycled material.
However, not all RPET is alike – some only includes “recycled” offcuts from the plastic manufacturing process rather than material that once graced consumers’ recycling bins. But unless it’s labelled as post-consumer plastic, you won’t be able to tell from the label.
Flight Plastics is the only local RPET manufacturer. All of its plastic is made from New Zealand-recycled material.
All other RPET is shipped in from overseas, though packaging manufacturer Alto said it tries to use New Zealand-recycled material in its RPET facilities whenever it can.
Flight Plastics and Alto say an RPET container costs the same as one made from virgin plastic, though the price of raw materials can vary. Custom-Pak, which also makes RPET, said “in many cases” it doesn’t charge more for packs with recycled content.
We surveyed the produce and bakery departments for items with hard plastic packaging at a Wellington-based Countdown, New World and Pak’nSave in May 2018. Packaging was examined to see what it was made from and if it had a plastic recycling code.
Our survey didn’t include the butchery department. Stores say they've switched to trays with recycled content for the majority of packaged meat.
Countdown: 27 types
New World: 20 types
Pak’nSave: 19 types
Countdown: 22 types
New World: 28 types
Pak’nSave: 14 types
New World: 8%
New World: 31%
New World: 26%
GUIDE Items purchased from Countdown Johnsonville Mall, New World Thorndon and Pak’nSave Petone, 14 to 18 May 2018. Results may vary for supermarkets in other locations. BAKERY DEPARTMENT and PRODUCE DEPARTMENT include all brands in the relevant department, including store-brands. TYPES show the number of different hard plastic containers and trays. MADE FROM PREVIOUSLY RECYCLED PLASTIC shows the percentage of containers that indicate they were made from recycled polyethylene terephthalate (RPET).
Foodstuffs said it will work with companies to “rectify” missing recycling codes. Countdown will also follow up with suppliers on the seven products we found lacking a recycling symbol.
Here are some easy ways to reduce your virgin plastic consumption:
Images of a pilot whale in Thailand that died after ingesting 80 plastic bags made headlines in June. The story illustrated the world’s growing plastic pollution problem. Millions of tonnes of the stuff are estimated to be littering our oceans.
In the same week as the whale's plight hit the news, 12 companies signed a declaration committing to using 100% reusable, recyclable or compostable packaging in their New Zealand operations by 2025. Countdown and Foodstuffs were signatories, along with Amcor, Danone, Frucor Suntory, L’Oréal, Mars, New Zealand Post, PepsiCo, The Coca-Cola Company, Unilever and Nestlé.
But the declaration isn’t without critics. Responding to the announcement, Greenpeace NZ oceans campaigner Emily Hunter said reducing the amount of plastic produced was crucial. “We’ve got plastic waste being stockpiled by councils ... there are no industrial-scale composting facilities for bioplastic and there are no bans on plastic bags, cutlery and other easy-to-eliminate plastic pollution. If we don’t eliminate and significantly reduce plastic packaging and single use plastics this problem won’t be fixed,” she said.
By Olivia Wannan
To help us get a fair deal for all New Zealanders, you can make a donation or bequest. We’ll use your contribution to investigate consumer issues and work for positive change.
Unlock all of Consumer from just $7 for 7 days or become a member from just $12 p/m