Allegations of misleading conduct, half-truths and innuendo – welcome to the world of retail optometry. Major chains OPSM and Specsavers were embroiled in court action over Specsavers' ads which OPSM claimed were misleading. The matter has finally been settled out of court.
Join today and get instant access to all test results and research.
The OPSM and Specsavers case stemmed from ads run by Specsavers in 2010 that compared its prices with those mystery shoppers had found at OPSM. Luxottica, OPSM's Italian-based owner, argued that the prices quoted for its specs were inaccurate and that the ads were likely to mislead consumers.
Luxottica's claim was dismissed by the High Court. But the Court of Appeal found the case should have gone to trial as it was "clearly arguable" the ads didn't represent OPSM's cheapest deals. Even if the figures were correct, the court considered the ads may still have been misleading because of the way the information was presented.
In a joint statement, the companies told us a confidential settlement has since been reached and that they're satisfied with the outcome. Neither is commenting further on the matter.
Specsavers may have taken a hit in this case but it's rapidly gaining ground in the glasses market. Since setting up shop here in 2008, the optometry giant has opened 52 stores and now boasts 30 percent of the market. Sales were worth $65.8 million in 2011.
The company's success has been aided by a high-profile marketing campaign, luring shoppers with discounted eye exams and 2-for-the-price-of-one deals on new glasses. Its advertising budget has gone from $3.9 million in 2010 to $7.1 million in 2011.
Rival Luxottica – which includes OPSM, Budget Eyewear and Sunglass Hut in its stable – operates 82 stores. According to its latest available annual accounts, Luxottica spent over $4 million on marketing here in the year to December 2010. It told us sales were worth $61 million in 2011.
While the big brands command centre stage, smaller players are fighting back. Eye Pro – a group of affiliated stores – ran an ad in 2011 stating, "when you see an optometrist you need to be certain ... that they're independently New Zealand owned and operated, not just making up the numbers for some multi-national chain peddling their own restricted range of cheap frames".
But Specsavers jumped on the ad, complaining to the Advertising Standards Authority. The company said it took strong objection to the wording which it claimed "by implication is seeking to denigrate Specsavers". The dispute was settled when Eye Pro amended the ad to remove the offending content.
Specsavers itself has received 2 warnings from the Commerce Commission for alleged misleading representations. Both warnings were issued in 2011 and related to product promotions that the commission considered may have been in breach of the Fair Trading Act.
While the ad wars look set to continue, are they leaving consumers any better off?
Price has always been the biggest gripe for consumers. For a product with a few basic components, the cost of glasses can seem staggering. But you're not just paying for the materials. Other retail costs are built into the price. With "designer" brands, you're also paying for the logo.
Price is Specsavers main drawcard. Its headline offer of glasses "from $69" is designed to attract shoppers looking for a cheaper deal. However, choices in this range are limited: just 26 of the 1000+ glasses it advertises retail for $69.
Most of its specs range from $299 to $499. These prices are for frames with single-vision lenses. If you need bifocals or progressive lenses, you'll pay at least another $200, although the store's 2-for-1 offers mean this may still seem like an attractive deal.
The lowest price we found advertised at OPSM was $119 for a pair of glasses with single-vision lenses. Visique (a locally owned co-operative) had a similar deal for $199 available at some stores. It told us lower-priced packages may be offered at individual stores or during promotional periods.
Prices for designer glasses – which get pride of place in many stores – are typically a lot higher. It's not uncommon to be quoted $500 for a fairly simple frame and lenses. Add-ons (such as anti-reflective or UV lens coatings) can quickly push up the price.
We haven't assessed the quality of glasses available from different outlets. But paying more won't necessarily mean you get a better class of glasses. The manufacturing of frames and lenses is dominated by a few major international companies. Some of the companies that make designer brands also make non-designer specs to the same standards.
Specsavers may have the edge on price, at least among its main bricks-and-mortar competitors. But many online retailers argue they can offer better deals because they don't have the same overheads as retail stores. It's possible to find specs online for a fraction of the price usually found in traditional outlets.
However, buying online isn't without risks. A recent investigation by UK consumer organisation Which? found 15 out of 36 glasses bought online weren't up to par. 10 had lenses that didn't meet required standards and 3 had dodgy frames. A further 10 were given a borderline pass.
The most serious problems were with multifocals. Which? experts found several companies sold these glasses without asking for vital information such as the wearer's vertical pupil position and pupillary distance (the distance between the centre of the pupils). This meant the glasses could be unsafe when driving or using stairs, Which? said.
Its experts suggested buying online might be fine for anyone with a simple prescription but had doubts about people with complex prescriptions going down this route. They also cautioned against buying from websites that don't ask for critical measurements – such as your pupillary distance.
An ageing population means the need for prescription glasses is set to rise. Eyesight usually begins to change around the age of 40. The New Zealand Association of Optometrists (NZAO) says most people will require glasses for reading to correct presbyopia (sometimes referred to as age-related long-sightedness).
Rates of myopia (short-sightedness) are also increasing – a phenomenon that some studies have linked to environmental and lifestyle changes, including more time spent in front of computers. The NZAO says recent epidemiological studies show a strong association between prolonged close work and myopia.
While advertising has focused heavily on price promotions, the NZAO is keen to stress that optometry involves more than selling glasses. Regardless of where you buy your specs, it recommends healthy adults should get an eye exam every 2 to 5 years.
Director Dr Lesley Frederikson says a comprehensive eye exam will take around 30 to 45 minutes and cover 9 specific checks, including questions about your medical history and assessment of the health of your eye to detect any sign of diseases such as glaucoma.
Ask your optometrist whether they're carrying out the checks recommended. A good optometrist will take time to explain what they're doing, what they find and what should happen next. Prices for eye exams vary. The cheapest price we found was $60 and the most expensive was $99.
Report by Jessica Wilson.
|Company||Number of outlets||Cost of eye exam ($)||Glasses, lowest advertised price ($)||Company structure|
|OPSM||49||70A||119||Owned by the Luxottica Group, a major Italian-based eyewear manufacturer and retailer that also owns Budget Eyewear (which is being phased out) and Sunglass Hut. House brands include Ray-Ban and Oakley. Also manufactures designer brands such as Prada, Ralph Lauren and Versace under license.|
|Specsavers||52||60B||69||Based in the Channel Islands and operates in the UK, Australia and several European countries. New Zealand stores operate as franchises.|
|Visique||67||VariesC||199||A co-operative of locally-owned optometrists. Frames sourced from several suppliers. Lenses sourced mainly from Essilor (one of the world's largest lens-manufacturers).|
Guide to the table
Prices are as at September 2012.
Glasses (lowest advertised price) is for frame plus single-vision lenses.
|Standard plastic lenses (CR39)||Cheapest lenses, usually used in advertised offers. Made from lightweight plastic.Suitable for single-vision, low- or medium-strength prescriptions.|
|Polycarbonate lenses||Impact-resistant lenses.Usually more expensive than standard plastic. Recommended for kids and people who play sport.|
|High-index lenses||Made from thinner, lightweight material.More expensive than other lenses.Suitable for strong prescriptions.|
|Bifocal lenses||Combines lenses for two different distances (such as close-up and long-distance).|
|Multifocal (progressive) lenses||Combines lenses for several different distances. The most expensive are called "tailor-made", "free-form", "high-definition" or "latest technology".|
|Anti-scratch||Standard on many lenses.Reduces scratching but no lenses are entirely scratch-proof.|
|Anti-reflection||Reduces reflection.Can be useful for night driving (reduces street- and car-light reflections).|
|UV protection||Shields eyes from ultraviolet rays.High-index, progressive and polycarbonate lenses are already UV-resistant.|
Guide to the table
Our table provides basic information about common lens types and coatings.
Yes. The Privacy Act gives you the right to access your personal health information. As a health consumer, you also have the right to be informed about the results of any tests, options for treatment, and the benefits and costs of these options.
It's not uncommon for people wearing new glasses to strike problems. Your optometrist may need to make minor adjustments to the findings from your eye exam to reach a prescription that's right for you. This is referred to as your "dispensed prescription".
Glasses are covered by the Consumer Guarantees Act (CGA). Where glasses aren't of acceptable quality, it's the retailer's responsibility to remedy the problem. However, if you're buying glasses from an overseas website, the CGA won't apply: you'll need to carefully check the retailer's trading history and returns policy.
If you only need glasses for reading, ready-made hobby or reading glasses may be an option. But you should get an eye test first to identify any problems.
With the exception of children's glasses, the purchase of prescription glasses isn't subsidised by the government. If you want to keep costs down, fitting new lenses to second-hand frames can be an option. Your optometrist may also have end-of-the-line-frames they're prepared to sell off cheaply.
Optometrists trained in New Zealand complete a Bachelor of Optometry at the University of Auckland. All optometrists have to be registered by the Optometrists and Dispensing Opticians Board. Only a registered optometrist can prescribe glasses or contact lenses. You can check an optometrist's qualifications and date of registration at www.odob.health.nz.
Thanks for requesting to reset your password. We've sent you an email with instructions on what you need to do. If you haven't received the email within the next five minutes please call us on 0800 266 786.
Sorry, the information you are trying to access is available to paying members only. Your membership helps us deliver our services and advocate for a fair deal for all New Zealand consumers.
Not a member yet? Avoid expensive mistakes and join more than 80,000 other savvy consumers making smart decisions.