Product review
Updated February 2023
Barbecues
We’ve tested barbecues in a range of sizes and prices to find the best performers that are also easy to use and clean.
From large patio-style models to smaller portable models, and prices ranging from $159 to $2600, there’s a barbecue here to suit most people.
What size barbecue?
There are two main considerations when deciding which size BBQ you should buy: how much space you have to entertain, and how many people you’ll usually feed – there’s no point investing in a big barbie if you’ll rarely feed a large crowd.
Patio/deck barbecues
A larger patio/deck barbecue is the best option for feeding the whole whānau. But you’ll need somewhere to store it. If you leave yours outside, get a heavy-duty cover.
Pros:
- ideal for feeding big groups
- typically have large cooking surfaces and three to six burners
- often have a side table and side burner (good for boiling a pot).
Cons:
- usually made of heavy parts, so can be tough to assemble
- mobility is generally limited to rolling between your cooking area and garage.
Portable barbecues
Some portables offer features once confined to larger models, such as hoods, hotplates and side tables.
Pros:
- ideal if you’re feeding fewer mouths
- easy to pack up and transport for a day out.
Cons:
- considerably smaller cooking areas than patio models
- only have one or two burners.
Fuel types
Gas
Gas is the most common fuel used for barbecues – the instant heat and adjustable temperature make for easy cooking. There’s a bit of maintenance required with a gas barbecue, as you need to regularly test the connection to make sure it’s not leaking. Running out of gas mid-cook can be a disaster, so check the levels before starting out. Gas bottles can be filled at some petrol stations, or you can take advantage of swap stations dotted around the country.
Charcoal
Charcoal lumps or briquettes are found at your local hardware or barbecue stores. There’s a bit of an art to lighting charcoal, and it can take a while to get up to temperature. The hot charcoal produces smoke that infuses into the food when the juices and fats drip down from the grill above. It’s certainly a lengthy process to cook with charcoal, but some swear the food is more flavoursome.
Electric
Electric barbecues require an outdoor power outlet or a lengthy extension cord running into the house. A benefit of going electric is you’ll never run out of fuel, so there’s no gas bottle anxiety. Most incorporate an element below the grill plates to provide the heat. One drawback is you can’t cook if the power goes out, unlike gas or charcoal grills that can keep on trucking.
Electricity and pellets
These barbecues cook food with the heat and smoke generated by slowly burning wood pellets that are fed from a hopper onto an electric element. Top models have a set and forget temperature control meaning the barbecue will automatically control the flow of burning pellets to maintain it. That means you can also cook with a “low and slow” method and let the smoke really impart its flavour into the food. These grills are a sizeable investment, and the costs can add up if you cook things hot and you chew through a lot of pellets.
Hybrid
These are a mix of fuels, usually a combo of gas and charcoal. You can run the barbecue on either fuel type. You can also easily light the charcoal with the gas burner to get things going quite quickly. You don’t see many of these models around, the ones we’ve seen haven’t blown us away with their gas cooking abilities.
Which BBQ materials will last?
Consider the materials in your barbecue’s body, trolley, burners, flame diffuser and cooking surfaces – they have a big effect on its lifespan.
Stainless steel
Stainless-steel models are the most corrosion-proof – and expensive – option, but they’re harder to clean and show smudges and fingerprints more than other surfaces.
Not all stainless-steel barbecues are created equal. The best are made from 304 grade stainless steel, which is more resistant to rust than other grades used for barbecues. When you’re shopping, take along a fridge magnet – it won’t stick to 304 grade stainless steel.
Painted- or powder-coated steel
These models will rust wherever the paint or powder wears through, which is likely after a few years of use. Aluminium is less corrosion-prone than untreated steel, but can develop oxidation (“white rust”). This is unsightly but won’t destroy your barbecue. Some steel or aluminium models are finished with vitreous enamel, which is far more durable than paint.
Cooking surfaces and burners
Cooking surfaces and burners are generally either cast iron or stainless steel. Cast iron can rust out quicker and need replacing, so we recommend stainless steel (or cast iron coated with vitreous enamel) for burners, cooking surfaces and flame diffusers.
Features and other considerations
Make sure you take these features into account while picking a barbecue.
Hood
A domed hood lets you roast as well as grill. Look for a hood with a bit of weight behind it and that it sits firmly back behind the grill when raised, so it won’t blow shut or obstruct your access to cooking surfaces or side plates. A hood thermometer lets you monitor the temperature while roasting; all the models in our test had one, but make sure it’s easy to read.
Hood handles
The hood handle should be durable and heat-resistant, and positioned so you don’t burn yourself using it.
Under the hood
- Cooking surfaces: Do you need grills, hotplates, or a mix of both? Grills sear food and let fat drip out, while hotplates are less likely to char food.
- Burners: A heavier gauge of metal lasts longer, so good-quality stainless steel is preferable to cast iron. More burners make it easier to cook a range of food at different speeds, but three or four are usually enough for the average family.
- Flame diffusers: Perforated metal plates that sit above the burners and below the cooking surface to evenly spread the heat from the flames. Look for flame diffusers set closer to the cooking surface than the burners, and angled to prevent fat dripping on to the burners, which can cause flare-ups.
BTUs and MJs
“British Thermal Units” and “Megajoules” measure heat output, and are commonly quoted by salespeople and manufacturers as a selling point. However, we found higher BTU/MJ burners don’t necessarily give better cooking performance or faster pre-heating, so these figures aren’t included in our test results. In fact, the amount of raw heat generated by each burner is less important than how evenly heat spreads across the cooking surfaces, and how reliably it maintains a constant temperature. If you’re worried about how quickly your barbecue will burn through gas, check the running times in our test results.
Controls and ignition
Look for large dials that stop firmly at their highest and lowest position, and don’t rattle in their housing or have a clumsy feel. Make sure they’re easy to read – dials set into an upward-slanting face are best. Some gas barbecues use a battery starter, while others use piezoelectric push button starters. Battery starters are generally quicker, but you’ll occasionally need to replace the battery.
Mobility
The bigger the wheels, the easier the barbecue is to move. Some models have four wheels with lockable castors, which means you can roll them without lifting one end. For a portable barbecue, check it’s light enough for you to lift into your car and is easy to dissemble.
Fat tray
This sits below the grill, and should be easy to take out and replace. We recommend lining the tray with tinfoil weighted with sand to make cleaning easier.
Side and rear/back burners
A side burner adds versatility – it allows you to boil a pot of rice or get a stir-fry going. Rear/back burners on the back “wall” can be used with a rotisserie accessory for roasting.
Safe grilling
Always use the hose and type of fitting recommended by the manufacturer. When you break out the BBQ for summer, check the hose for blockages and make sure all connections fit snugly. Never, ever use a gas barbecue inside.
Stability
Make sure it doesn’t rock. If you want to take it camping or on picnics, look for easily detachable legs.
Cleaning
Check the barbecue is easy to take apart and reassemble.
Spare parts
Check spare parts are available.
Warming rack
This allows you to keep cooked food warm.
Top Brand
Our Top Brand awards help Consumer members find the best brands. Only brands that consistently make products that work well, last a long time, and have happy owners, earn our endorsement.
Which brand is most reliable?
We ask thousands of Consumer members about their products to find out which brands are most reliable and satisfying to own. The results are available to members and Digital Pass holders.
We've tested 31 barbecues.
Find the right one for you.
This field should be left blank